The Pulse of Franconia Ridge

Nathaniel Scrimshaw

I had hoped we would see a lull after Labor Day. No such luck. On Saturday, September 12, the Franconia Ridge counter recorded 1,265 passes. We now also have the number for Labor Day Sunday: 1,381, close to the record-setting 1,441 recorded on August 15. Eight of the last nine weekends have now included a day with more than 1,000 passes.

The graphs above put this change into perspective. During roughly comparable periods in 2014, 2024, and 2026, the number of days exceeding 500 passes increased from 9 to 19 to 20. But the more striking change is happening at the extreme end.

In 2014, only one day exceeded 900, topping out at 952. In 2024, four days exceeded 900, with one breaking 1,000 at 1,137. This year, eight days have exceeded 1,000, with our highest days reaching 1,203, 1,210, 1,265, 1,381, and 1,441.

Not many years ago, we thought of a 700-person day as extreme, something associated with a beautiful Fourth of July, Labor Day, or Indigenous Peoples’ Day weekend. Those extremes have steadily crept upward: 700 became 800, then 900, then 1,000. This summer we are repeatedly seeing 1,200 to 1,400.

The important point isn’t simply that there are more hikers.

The character of high-use days on Franconia Ridge is changing.

The Pulse Within the Wave

For years I have referred to the surge of hikers moving onto Franconia Ridge on busy mornings as “the wave.” Last year I explored this more formally through an analogy with fluid dynamics: hikers flow along the trail, gather in “eddies” at summits and viewpoints, encounter constrictions, and spill beyond the tread when the available space becomes insufficient. 

Our new trail-counter data suggest another way of looking at the same system:

Franconia Ridge has a pulse.

Look at the daily graphs and you can see a rhythm. Use rises and falls through the week, followed by the great weekend pulse. Zoom into a single busy day using our new counter, which records hikers in 15-minute intervals, and another rhythm appears inside it. The morning wave builds toward midday, but that wave itself consists of smaller pulses and clusters of hikers moving across the Ridge.

There are rhythms nested within rhythms: the seasonal pattern, the weekly weekend pulse, the daily wave, and the smaller clusters within that wave.

The cardiovascular analogy is useful because a circulatory system isn’t affected by volume alone. Rhythm, flow, constriction, pressure, and the condition of the system itself all interact.

And that brings us to something we learned this summer that complicates our thinking.

Off-Trail Behavior: A More Complicated Picture

We had hypothesized that increasing crowding would produce a surge in off-trail behavior: as the number of hikers increased, the percentage stepping off the trail would rise sharply.

Students in this summer’s White Mountain Environmental Field School systematically observed off-trail behavior and compared those observations with our counter data.

The results did not demonstrate the surge we expected.

People went off-trail even at lower measured flow rates, and the percentage leaving the tread did not clearly increase with hourly visitation.

But those observations didn’t disprove the hypothesis either. Most of our observations occurred during generally high-use periods, so we never established a good baseline for truly quiet conditions. We were also comparing observations with hourly counts, which may conceal the very phenomenon we are trying to understand.

Forty hikers distributed relatively evenly across an hour are very different from thirty of those hikers arriving within ten minutes.

Clustering may matter as much as overall volume.

There is also another possibility: the threshold at which crowding begins to influence behavior may simply be much lower than we thought.

Even at relatively modest hourly counts, hikers move in groups. They meet parties traveling in the opposite direction. Faster hikers and runners overtake slower hikers. People stop to rest or take photographs. At a high step or narrow scramble, several people arriving together may temporarily exceed the effective capacity of that small piece of trail.

This makes the new 15-minute data particularly valuable. We need to look not only at the number of people using Franconia Ridge, but at the amplitude and rhythm of the pulse within the wave.

A Cardiovascular System Under Stress

This brings us back to those extraordinary numbers from 2026.

A healthy cardiovascular system can accommodate changing demands. The heart beats faster, flow increases, vessels respond, and eventually the system returns toward normal.

But repeated extreme pulses acting upon a system with existing constrictions are another matter.

Franconia Ridge increasingly feels like a system under chronic cardiovascular stress.

The “arteries” themselves are compromised in places. Narrow scrambles, high steps, rough tread, poorly defined trail edges, and crowded summits create something analogous to stenoses, places where the available channel narrows.

People stop in the flow. Faster hikers and runners pass slower groups. Opposing traffic tries to negotiate the same narrow passage. Hikers accumulate. Eventually the stream spills sideways.

In the cardiovascular analogy, some of our trail work begins to look like medical intervention. Strategic widening opens constricted sections. Reconstructing excessively high steps can reduce places where hikers routinely go around obstacles. Better-defined tread helps keep circulation within the intended channel. Pullouts give people somewhere to rest, talk, eat, or enjoy a view without stopping in the main flow.

In a very loose sense, carefully widening a chronic pinch point is a little like placing a stent. We aren’t proposing to widen the entire Franconia Ridge Trail. We are identifying the places where circulation repeatedly breaks down and increasing capacity precisely where it is needed.

But no physician would treat serious cardiovascular disease simply by inserting more stents.

And we cannot build our way out of everything happening on Franconia Ridge.

When Extreme Use Becomes a Crisis

What does a 1,441-person wave mean when our observations suggest that off-trail behavior is already occurring at a fraction of that volume?

Perhaps these extraordinary days are analogous not simply to elevated blood pressure, but to an acute cardiovascular crisis imposed upon a system already experiencing chronic stress.

This is an analogy or metaphor, of course. But it provides a useful way of thinking about the condition of the Ridge. We have recurring extreme pulses, physical constrictions, a fragile surrounding environment, and indications that impacts occur well before we reach our most spectacular visitor counts.

There is also another part of the system that our automated counters cannot measure: human behavior.

Our Summit Stewards are encountering not simply more people, but increasingly difficult interactions. There have been instances of hikers and runners ignoring requests to remain on the trail, deliberately walking across fragile alpine vegetation after being asked not to, and responding rudely or defiantly to stewards trying to protect the Ridge.

That matters.

The effective capacity of a trail isn’t determined solely by its width, grade, and surface. It also depends upon how people behave within that space.

A thousand people who consistently remain on a well-defined tread present a very different management problem from a thousand people among whom a significant number cut corners, pass outside the tread, congregate on vegetation, or disregard stewardship messages.

So perhaps we need to think about the health of Franconia Ridge in terms of three interacting dimensions:

The pulse: How many people arrive, when they arrive, and how strongly they cluster.

The circulation: Whether the physical trail has sufficient capacity to move those people without expanding the human footprint into the surrounding alpine zone.

Behavior: How people move through the system and whether visitors respond to trail boundaries, stewardship, education, and the vulnerability of the landscape.

Seen this way, we are no longer simply managing a popular trail.

We are managing a trail system experiencing recurring episodes of extreme use in an extraordinarily fragile alpine environment, with signs that both its physical and social capacity are under severe strain.

I think it is fair to call that a crisis.

From Metaphor to Management

Calling something a crisis shouldn’t imply despair. It should change the urgency and scale of our response.

Some of that response can happen directly on the Ridge.

One possibility we are exploring is expanding the role and training of our Summit Stewards. Stewards spend hundreds of hours observing how people actually move across Franconia Ridge. They see where circulation repeatedly breaks down: high steps that hikers walk around, pinch points where passing forces people outside the tread, poorly defined trail edges, places where hikers repeatedly step onto vegetation, and summits and viewpoints where people need somewhere to get out of the moving stream.

With additional training in trail reconstruction and stonework, Summit Stewards could devote part of their work week not simply to observing these problems, but to fixing them: reconstructing high steps, defining tread, strategically widening chronic pinch points, creating pullouts, installing appropriate barriers, and continually adapting the trail to what we are learning from visitor behavior.

That would represent an important evolution in alpine stewardship: education, observation, trail maintenance, restoration, and adaptive management becoming parts of the same job.

However, When Franconia Ridge repeatedly receives 1,000 to 1,400 passes in a day, the U.S. Forest Service and New Hampshire State Parks need to seriously examine options for reducing or redistributing the largest pulses before they reach the alpine zone.

That conversation should include a range of possibilities: parking and transportation policies, some form of reservation, permit, or timed-entry system during periods of extreme use, and perhaps development of an attractive lower-elevation loop that provides less experienced hikers with an alternative to committing themselves to the entire Franconia Ridge Loop.

A lower loop could be particularly interesting because it isn’t simply a restriction. It creates another choice: a rewarding mountain experience more appropriate to the abilities, available time, or expectations of some of the people who currently enter the eight-mile alpine loop.

No single intervention is likely to solve the problem.

That is precisely the point of Integrated Trail Management.

We need to work simultaneously on the pulse, the circulation, and behavior within the system: moderate extreme volumes where necessary; improve the physical trail where constrictions create predictable impacts; provide alternatives where appropriate; and strengthen stewardship, education, and trail definition so visitors understand how to move through this extraordinarily fragile landscape.

The numbers from 2026 suggest that we have entered a different era on Franconia Ridge. A decade ago, a 700-person day could be considered extreme. This summer we have repeatedly exceeded 1,000 and reached 1,441. At the same time, our field observations suggest that off-trail behavior is not confined to those extraordinary days. The system may begin showing signs of stress at much lower levels of use than we previously assumed.

That changes the question.

We should no longer ask simply:

How many hikers can Franconia Ridge accommodate?

We should be asking:

What combination of visitor volume, trail design, visitor behavior, stewardship, and management will allow people to experience Franconia Ridge without continuing to expand the human footprint across the alpine zone?

The objective isn’t to stop the heart. We want people to experience these mountains.

The challenge is to restore a healthier pulse and build a trail and management system capable of sustaining it.

That is no longer an abstract discussion about carrying capacity. It is the management challenge now in front of us.

From Trail Counters to Agent-Based Models: Understanding Crowding on Franconia Ridge

One of the questions we have been asking over the last several years: When does a busy trail become a crowded trail?

The trail counter on Franconia Ridge provides part of the answer. It records the number of visitors passing a point on the ridge and, importantly, the direction they are traveling. Looking at the data by hour reveals a remarkably consistent daily rhythm. Visitor traffic builds rapidly through the morning, generally peaks between 11:00 a.m. and 1:00 p.m., and then declines through the afternoon.

But not all days are alike. Saturdays operate in an entirely different realm from most weekdays. During the summer we recorded several Saturdays with more than 1,000 visitors. On August 15 the trail experienced a record 1,441 visitors in a single day—a record number. This last Saturday, August 22, we also exceeded 1000, with 1133. Our observations suggest that under these very high-use conditions, off-trail behavior also increases sharply.

The new counter WTN Americas/Pan American Trails placed on the ridge this summer can provide data at 15-minute intervals, allowing us to look inside those busy hours. What we find is that visitors do not necessarily move across the ridge in a steady stream. They often arrive in small waves or pulses within a larger single wave , not unlike the traffic patterns that develop on a highway during periods of congestion.

On August 15, for example, one 15-minute period contained 73 visitors and another contained 75. More importantly, the pressure was sustained. For nearly five hours, every consecutive 15-minute interval contained at least 35 visitors, and for four hours the count remained at or above 40 per interval.

Volume, Intensity, Persistence, Encounters, and Passing

This suggests that crowding has several dimensions. Daily volume tells us how many people are using the trail. Intensity tells us how concentrated that use becomes over short periods. Persistence tells us how long those conditions continue.

Intensity can occur without high volume; persistence generally cannot. A large group, or simply the happenstance of several groups arriving at the same time, can create a short burst of intense use on an otherwise quiet day. But for high-intensity conditions to persist over hours, there must be enough visitors in the system to continually replenish the flow.

Because the counter records direction of travel, we can also distinguish visitors traveling north from those traveling south. When visitors traveling in opposite directions meet, we call these encounters. Two 15-minute periods containing 60 visitors therefore may represent very different conditions. If nearly everyone is traveling in one direction, there will be relatively few opportunities for head-on encounters. If 30 are traveling north and 30 south, the potential for encounters is much greater.

There is another kind of interaction: passing. Visitors traveling in the same direction move at different speeds, so faster visitors overtake slower ones.

Both encounters and passing matter because trail conditions help determine what happens when visitors interact. On a wide, relatively smooth section of trail, two visitors may pass without difficulty. At a narrow section, high step, rugged scramble, pinch point, or location where the trail boundary is unclear, the same interaction may require someone to stop, wait, squeeze past, or step off the established tread.

It becomes more complicated when we consider different types of visitors. In 2025, International Trails Fellow Rod Goés observed differences in interactions involving hikers and runners. When hikers approach one another from opposite directions, one or both may move off the tread to get by. When a hiker sees a runner approaching from the opposite direction, however, the hiker may stop and step aside, often onto a durable surface. A runner overtaking a hiker from behind presents a different situation: the hiker may not know the runner is approaching, leaving the runner to move around the hiker, sometimes in a broad arc beyond the established tread.

This gives us a more nuanced way of thinking about the relationship between visitor use and trail impacts:

visitor flow → encounters & passing → interaction with visitor type & trail conditions → behavioral response

The Importance of a Trail Audit

The White Mountain Environmental Field School’s trail audit adds another part of the information needed to understand this process. In 2026, students and stewards mapped many of the physical conditions associated with off-trail movement, including high steps, narrow tread, pinch points, rugged surfaces, and poorly defined trail boundaries. They also identified locations where off-trail use is already occurring.

Bringing these observations together with the counter data may allow us to test a more interesting hypothesis. Off-trail behavior may not simply increase steadily as the number of visitors increases. Instead, there may be points at which repeated encounters and passing at particular locations begin to produce surges in off-trail movement.

One visitor steps aside to let another pass. A second person follows the same line. As traffic continues, what began as an individual response can become an informal passing lane or alternate route. In this way, a combination of visitor flow, human behavior, and trail design may produce impacts that cannot be explained by visitor numbers alone.

Modeling Visitor Behavior

How can we put all these pieces together? One promising tool is an agent-based model, or ABM. The idea is simpler than the name suggests. Instead of treating 1,000 visitors as a single number, a computer model represents them as individual visitors moving along a simplified version of the trail. Some travel north, others south. They move at different speeds, encounter and pass one another, and eventually respond to features such as narrow tread, high steps, or pinch points. The model can use the actual waves of northbound and southbound visitors recorded by our trail counter rather than assuming that visitors arrive at a constant rate.

We can then ask whether relatively simple rules governing individual behavior produce the larger patterns we observe on the ridge. Do off-trail movements begin to cluster at particular locations as traffic increases? Do short pulses of visitors matter differently from sustained congestion? What happens when opposing streams of visitors meet at a pinch point? And could widening a short section of tread, providing a passing area, clarifying a trail boundary, or changing a high step reduce the predicted off-trail surge?

An ABM would not tell us exactly what every visitor will do, nor would it replace observations on the ground. Instead, it provides a kind of virtual trail laboratory where counter data, trail conditions, and field observations can be brought together and different explanations tested. If the model can reproduce patterns we actually observe on Franconia Ridge, we can then use it to explore how relatively small changes in trail design or management might change those patterns.

Ultimately, the question is not simply “How many visitors are too many?” A more useful question may be:

Under what combinations of visitor flow, encounters, passing, visitor types, and trail conditions does off-trail behavior begin to increase?

Answering that question could help us move beyond broad ideas of trail “carrying capacity” toward something much more practical: understanding how heavily used alpine trails function under pressure, identifying where problems are most likely to develop, and designing targeted interventions that accommodate visitors while better protecting the alpine landscape.